Three things to check in your HR file before Monday

Most compliance problems in a small business are not decisions that went the wrong way. They are things that were correct once and were never revisited.

That distinction matters, because it changes what you are looking for. You are not auditing your own judgment. You are looking for the places where time passed and noticing was nobody’s job.

Which is good news, in a way. It means the search is mechanical. Below are three checks. All three run against files you already have, none of them requires hiring anybody to look, and you can get through all three in about fifteen minutes at your desk.

The uncomfortable part is that finding these is the hard part. Fixing them, once they have a name, is mostly scheduling.

Check one: the date on your handbook

Open the file and find the date on it.

Then ask a second question, which is the one that actually tells you something: how many of your current employees were hired after that date?

If the answer is most of them, you are not holding a policy document. You are holding a record of what your policies used to be, distributed to people who were not there when it was written. Nothing about that is dishonest. It just is not a description of your business anymore.

A handbook makes a claim. It says these are our current policies and they meet the requirements that apply to us. That claim was true on the day it was signed off, and it has been quietly aging ever since, because requirements move and files do not.

There is a specific failure mode here worth naming. It is not that the handbook is missing something. It is that it still contains something. A policy you stopped following two years ago is worse than no policy, because it is written evidence of a standard you are not meeting. The paid time off accrual you changed informally. The remote work language from 2021 that nobody has read since. The complaint procedure that routes to a manager who left.

You usually find out about this in one particular way, and it is not during a review. It is when somebody else reads your handbook back to you, in a situation where you would very much prefer it said something different.

Five minutes. Date, headcount hired after it, and a skim for anything you know you no longer do.

Check two: where your people actually work

Write down every state your employees physically work in. Not where the business is registered. Not where payroll is run. Where the human being is sitting when they do the job.

Now write down the states your policies actually address by name.

If those two lists do not match, you have found the most common gap in small-business HR right now, and remote hiring is why. This used to be a problem for companies with legal departments. Then a twelve person business hired two people in two other states and inherited two more bodies of employment law without ever deciding to.

The state layer is the layer that moves. It varies more, it changes more often, and it follows the employee rather than the employer. Leave, pay transparency in job postings, final paycheck timing, sick time, notice requirements: these are all set at the state level and they are not the same in any two places. It is also the layer a downloaded template cannot handle, because a template does not know where your people live.

Two traps in this check specifically. The first is the employee who moved and told you conversationally rather than in writing, so your records still show the old address. The second is the part-time or seasonal person you did not think of as an employee for this purpose. Both count. Write them down.

Check three: who manages people, and what you can prove

List everyone in your business who supervises another person. Include the people who do it in practice without the title, because the law tends to care about function rather than what is printed on the org chart.

Then, for each name, answer one question. What training can you actually evidence?

Not what they know. Not what you told them in the truck on the way to a job. What is recorded, dated, tied to a named person, and retrievable in an afternoon.

This is the check that surprises people, because most owners have had the conversation. They have explained how to document a performance problem or what not to say in a difficult meeting. They just have no record it happened, and a manager’s good instincts are not a defense you can produce later.

It is also the check most likely to be an actual legal requirement rather than a good practice, depending on where those people sit. In California, employers with five or more employees have to provide sexual harassment prevention training: two hours for supervisors, one hour for everyone else, within six months of hire or promotion, and again every two years. Because that interval is two years, the retraining lands in even-numbered years for most employers, and 2026 is one. In New York, the training is annual, and the requirement applies to every employer in the state regardless of size, including one-person businesses. Neither of those thresholds is high enough to exclude you.

If any name on your list works in a state with a training mandate and you cannot produce a dated completion record for them, that is not a gray area. It is a gap with a date attached.

What to do with what you find

Nothing on that list is a crisis. A named gap is a budgetable gap. The hard part was finding it, and you just did that in less time than a lunch.

Fix in this order:

1. Anything affecting a current employee right now. An open leave request, a live performance issue, a person working in a state your policies do not mention.
2. Anything with a deadline attached. Training cycles and filing dates do not negotiate.
3. Policy language. Real, worth doing, and never the emergency.

If you want the longer version of this, with the other places gaps tend to cluster, we wrote it up here: the HR compliance gaps small employers actually have. If you would rather not do it by hand, the HR Health Check asks the same questions and scores the answers.

And all three of these checks can be run inside AllMyHR without paying anything. The Smart Employee Handbook shows you what your current policies would look like if they were current, including the state layer for every state your people are in. The 300+ course library covers the manager training gap and issues a dated completion certificate for each course, which is the evidence check three is asking for. A credentialed advisor will read your findings and tell you which of them actually matters this month.

---

Start for free. Free for 30 days. No credit card required. Cancel anytime.

Start for free or see what is included.